
Do you have a particular obsession with one dish; an obsession so deep that anytime you notice it on a restaurant menu you have to order it, despite your better judgment telling you there is no way in hell that particular place (particularly a chain brand eatery) could ever perfect such a dish? I’m that way with French onion soup, my favorite comfort food of all time. I can vaguely recall the night my dad made it for our family and friends of our family, well over twenty years ago.
There is a local, authentic French bistro that has the best French onion soup, but on those occasions when I (a) don’t want to pay for it (b) don’t want to wait and (c) want to have leftovers I needed to come up with the best recipe I could refine. My mom used to make it out of low-sodium chicken broth, when low-sodium beef broth was unavailable. It was a decent substitute for many years, but far from the quality we became accustomed to since frequenting our bistro. It was time to hunt down and refine a new recipe. I formed this recipe using Alton Brown’s recipe as a base.
What I Used:
Onions: 5 yellow onions, 3 tablespoons of butter (I use smart balance), 1/2c. sherry
Broth: 32 oz. certified organic beef broth, 14 oz. low-sodium chicken broth, 14 oz. canned beef broth, 1/2 c. spiced apple cider, 3/4th c. white wine (chardonnay)
Spice: Allspice, cloves, black pepper, thyme, sea salt & cumin – lots of cumin!
French bread & shredded Gruyere cheese (I used Trader Joe’s brand and I’ll never switch it up unless they do it first)
How much does this make? A shit ton (maybe 6-8). I also use regular bowls, not special mini soup crocks. Step by step instructions with pictures are as follows:
Chop the two largest onions into fine, half-moon shapes:

Yummy chunky onions
Finely mince the remaining three, smaller onions (I used a food processor) then set them aside.

Best investment mom ever made
Heat up a skillet and melt the butter on high. Once the butter is melted, layer the chopped, half-moon shaped onions and let them sweat down and brown on medium heat until they reduced to a rich caramel color. This takes awhile, 30-45 minutes. Add the 1/2c. sherry, reduced heat and stir.

Smells delicious
In a large pot, add the liquids (beef broth, chicken broth, cider, wine), the minced onions we set aside earlier and the spices (I repeat, be generous with the cumin).

The liquids I used for the broth
Bring to a boil, then add the caramelized onions from the skillet, reduce heat & simmer for about 20-30 minutes, fiddling with your spices until you have the taste you like.

Try not to drool
While that’s going, this is the perfect time to grate the Gruyere cheese. Our food processor has a grater blade *grin*

Cheese!
When the soup is done and the cheese is grated, it’s time to cut the French bread in small rounds and toast them.

Toasty toast!
Ladle the soup in a bowl (or mini crock bowl, whatever), add the toast in the soup, (don’t burn yourself) and sprinkle the cheese on top. Then, place the bowl(s) on a cookie sheet and into a pre-heated oven set for “broil” ~ around 400-500 degrees F.

Hot oven is hot.
In anywhere from 3-5 minutes, the cheese will have melted and bubbled and it’s time to turn off the oven and carefully remove the soup ~

Be careful, it’s crazy hot!
Grab a soup spoon, dig in and enjoy!
NOTES:
To veganize! simply use vegetable stock and add a vegan ‘beef’ bouillon.
Question: What is your favorite soup?